Teacher Absences During Jeffco School Dispute Are Ruled Open Records

The Colorado Supreme Court last week declined to review a state appeals court decision holding that sick-leave records are not part of a public school teacher’s confidential personnel file.

The denial of certiorari means that Golden parent Kathy Littlefield will finally get the names of teachers who called in sick from four Jefferson County high schools over two days in September 2014.

Some of the teachers said at the time they were taking “collective action” to protest school board policies. When Littlefield requested the teachers’ names, the Jefferson County Education Association sued to block their release. The union lost in district court, and the Colorado Court of Appeals upheld the lower court’s decision in January.

SupremeCourtbuildingsmall“I still want the names,” Littlefield said last Monday. “Those teachers could transfer to the school where my kids are at, and I’d like to know who they are. I think other parents would like to know too.”

Attorneys for the union contended that teacher-absence records are private and protected from disclosure under the personnel files exemption of the Colorado Open Records Act (CORA). The records sought by Littlefield, they claimed, are “a classic example of information maintained because of the employer-employee relationship” that must not be disclosed to the public under CORA.

The Court of Appeals, however, held that this phrase in the open-records law – “information maintained because of the employer-employee relationship” – refers to information “of the same general nature as an employee’s home address and telephone number or personal financial information.”

The appellate court noted that “a teacher’s absence is directly related to the teacher’s job as a public employee.” It added that sick-leave records pertain to language in CORA that requires disclosure of “any compensation, including expense allowances and benefits, paid to employees by the state, its agencies, institutions, or political subdivisions.”

Because the Court of Appeals’ ruling stands, it is now a binding decision that may help determine the outcome of a separate government-employee records case pending in Arapahoe County District Court.

A judge last week heard arguments in that case, which involves complaints and disciplinary actions against Cherry Creek School District bus drivers, requested by 9NEWS for recent stories on school bus safety. As in the Jeffco case, government-employee unions have sued to block the release of the records, claiming they are part of a driver’s confidential personnel file.

9NEWS attorney Steve Zansberg, who is president of the Colorado Freedom of Information Coalition, disputed that argument in court, noting the Court of Appeals’ narrow construction of the personnel records exemption. The exemption applies only to “information that is highly personal and private,” he said, not to information related to a public employee’s job performance.

The CFOIC has intervened in the bus driver records case on the side of 9NEWS as have The Denver Post, KCNC-TV, KDVR-TV, KMGH-TV and the Associated Press. The CFOIC and several news organizations submitted friend-of-the-court briefs in the Jeffco sick-leave records case.

Jeffco school district attorney Craig Hess said Monday he would respond to Littlefield’s CORA request later in the day.

__

Follow the Colorado Freedom of Information Coalition on Twitter @CoFOIC. Like CFOIC’s Facebook page.

 

One thought on “Teacher Absences During Jeffco School Dispute Are Ruled Open Records

  1. So, we have a vigilante who wishes the names of the teachers who called in sick TWO YEARS AGO! One does wonder exactly why she needs these names. I hope that it is not to harass the teachers or follow their children and intimidate them.
    I would be concerned that this self appointed vigilante is out to do some harm to these teachers. Who is next? The students who left classes?
    If this person really cared about the quality of education then the lawsuit money would have been better spent of mentoring students.
    For the record, I am a Farmer, not a teacher or a union member. I help to raise the food …this lady eats.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *